Monroe County, FL Crime News
Browse Monroe County, Florida crime and public-safety reporting from County Crime Watch.
All individuals are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in a court of law.
Arrest on Big Pine Key after late-night disturbance; deputy struck, threats alleged
A woman from Naples was arrested on Big Pine Key after a late-night disturbance at an undisclosed area, the Monroe County Sheriff’s Office reports. Deputies responded at approximately 2 a.m. on Oct. 11 following a call about a disturbance; the agency
Monroe County resident targeted by jury-duty money-demand scam in Key West
Monroe County law enforcement says a resident in Key West was targeted with a fraudulent money demand alleging they missed federal jury duty. The Monroe County Sheriff’s Office received the report after the resident got both regular and electronic ma
Man sentenced to life for Key Largo resort murder in Monroe County
A Monroe County man was sentenced to life in prison without parole after a jury found him guilty of murdering a woman whose body was discovered at a Key Largo resort. Circuit Judge James Morgan imposed the life term on October 9, 2026; the defendant
Florida Keys felon captured in Mexico after fleeing ahead of trial; booked in Miami‑Dade
A fugitive wanted by the Monroe County Sheriff’s Office was located in Mexico and returned to custody after eluding authorities during the final day of his trial. Monroe County officials allege the man, identified in jail records as Armando Lopez, fa
DNA testing identifies 1999 Keys cold-case woman known as 'Cinnamon' in Key West
Monroe County investigators announced this week that remains found in 1999 off Key West have been identified as Cumie Doylene McCutcheon. Deputies originally recovered the body aboard a moored boat in September 1999 and were unable to determine her i
Man arrested after alleged unauthorized charges at Islamorada resort
Monroe County deputies arrested a 26-year-old Clearwater man on Oct. 3 after an Islamorada resort guest reported unauthorized charges to her room. The Cheeca Lodge & Spa called the sheriff’s office in September 2025 when a guest discovered nearly $90
Monroe County Fire Rescue runs Fire Prevention Week outreach in six schools and daycares
Monroe County Fire Rescue (MCFR) conducted a weeklong Fire Prevention Week outreach program across its jurisdiction from Oct. 5–9, 2026, visiting six local schools and daycares to teach chldren about device-related fire risks. The program was held in
Monroe County fugitive captured in Mexico after skipping trial
A convicted felon from the Florida Keys was seized in Mexico after failing to appear at his trial in the Keys, Monroe County authorities said. Armando Lopez, 53, of Key Largo, did not show for the final day of a trial in Islamorada and was located ab
Armed burglary and robbery alleged at Saddlebunch Keys residence
Monroe County deputies say an armed intruder entered a Lower Keys home and took a resident’s phone while she was attempting to call 911. The Monroe County Sheriff’s Office identified the accused as 32-year-old Anley Olicier and says the incident occu
Defendant Flees During Trial After December 2024 Key Largo Violence; Monroe County Agencies Searching
A man accused in a violent December 2024 incident in Key Largo remains at large after skipping the final day of his jury trial in Monroe County. According to charging documents and the Monroe County Sheriff’s Office, the case began on Dec. 22, 2024,
Islamorada hotel fraud leads to arrest; Monroe County deputies probe charges
A reported scheme to charge a hotel guest’s account at a resort in Islamorada prompted a Monroe County Sheriff’s Office response after the guest discovered unauthorized charges in September 2025. Deputies say the resort’s security later issued reimbu
Suspect in Plantation Key Attempted Murder Trial Fails to Appear; Monroe County Deputies Search
Monroe County deputies are actively searching for a 53-year-old man who failed to appear for an ongoing attempted murder trial in Plantation Key. The Monroe County Sheriff's Office reports the defendant, identified as Armando Lopez, did not show an u
Monroe County jury convicts former Trauma Star division chief on 10 counts
A Monroe County jury found former Monroe County Fire Rescue EMS and Trauma Star Division Chief Andrea Arlene Thompson guilty on 10 criminal charges following a six-day trial that concluded Sept. 30, 2026. The convictions relate to conduct that arose
Monroe County corrections officer arrested in Key West on aggravated stalking charge
A Monroe County Sheriff’s Office corrections officer was arrested in Key West early Friday morning on a felony aggravated stalking charge, authorities said. The officer was booked into jail after Key West police took him into custody shortly before 1
Former Monroe County Trauma Star Division Chief Convicted in Probe of Flight Nurse substance Thefts
A former division chief for the Monroe County Fire Rescue air ambulance program was convicted on multiple felony counts after a six-day trial, prosecutors announced. Andrea Arlene Thompson was found guilty on 10 counts arising from her conduct during
Stock Island residence searched; two men arrested after weapons and narcotics found
Monroe County Sheriff’s Office detectives executed a residential search warrant on a Stock an undisclosed area, resulting in the arrest of two men and the seizure of multiple firearms and narcotics. The search, conducted by Special Operations detecti