Crime & Public Safety

DNA testing identifies 1999 Keys cold-case woman known as 'Cinnamon' in Key West

By

DNA testing identifies 1999 Keys cold-case woman known as 'Cinnamon' in Key West

Monroe County investigators announced this week that remains found in 1999 off Key West have been identified as Cumie Doylene McCutcheon. Deputies originally recovered the body aboard a moored boat in September 1999 and were unable to determine her identity for nearly three decades. According to the Monroe County Sheriff’s Office, recent DNA research by the Florida Department of Law Enforcement linked the remains to McCutcheon. The agency says detectives were notified of the FDLE match this year and that a DNA sample from the woman’s son confirmed the identification. The Monroe County Medical Examiner’s Office also assisted in the case. Agency action in the file focused on modern DNA testing and interagency collaboration rather than new on-scene evidence; the identification resulted from laboratory comparisons rather than fresh physical investigation. The facts documented by the Sheriff’s Office are that a body was recovered in September 1999, that FDLE research produced a genealogical/DNA lead, and that the son’s test corroborated the match to Cumie Doylene McCutcheon. The Sheriff’s Office characterized the resolution as providing closure to the family and credited the staff who worked on the case. No additional investigative conclusions, causes of death, criminal charges, or pending actions were reported in the agency release.

More Monroe County news · Request a correction or case update