post
Islamorada hotel fraud leads to arrest; Monroe County deputies probe charges
A reported scheme to charge a hotel guest’s account at a resort in Islamorada prompted a Monroe County Sheriff’s Office response after the guest discovered unauthorized charges in September 2025. Deputies say the resort’s security later issued reimbursements totaling about $2,419 for the disputed purchases. Monroe County detectives learned the guest had been charged roughly $900 in food, drinks, hats and other items without the guest’s knowledge, according to the agency. Investigators worked with the resort’s security team and with Clearwater police during the probe. Deputies arrested 26-year-old Malachi Ethan Keasler on suspicion of grand theft, possession of another person’s identification, and scheme to defraud, the sheriff’s office reported. Agency accounts state that the resort had already processed refunds to cover the disputed charges. Detectives attribute the alleged billing activity to a scheme involving multiple people; authorities say another person identified in the investigation, 24-year-old Emma Camille Wallace, was arrested in December 2025 and faces charges similar to those lodged against Keasler. The Monroe County Sheriff’s Office has characterized the matter as an alleged theft and fraud investigation. Keasler’s arrest and the earlier reimbursements are documented actions by law enforcement and resort security; an undisclosed area outcomes were not reported in the agency summary provided to deputies’ public communications. All individuals accused of a crime are presumed innocent an undisclosed area.
More Monroe County news · Request a correction or case update
All individuals mentioned in criminal allegations are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in a court of law.