Monroe County, FL Crime News
Browse Monroe County, Florida crime and public-safety reporting from County Crime Watch.
All individuals are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in a court of law.
Man arrested in Monroe County on grand theft and fraud charges linked to rental listing scam
A man was arrested in the Florida Keys after deputies tied him to an alleged fraudulent vacation rental transaction involving a Big Pine Key property. The Monroe County Sheriff’s Office says the case began when a person attempting to rent a property
Marathon driver accused of DUI, hit-and-run and fleeing deputies after two crashes
A Marathon motorist is facing multiple criminal charges after deputies say she struck another occupied vehicle, left the scene, and later fled from law enforcement before crashing again. The Monroe County Sheriff’s Office reports the first an undiscl
Four juveniles arrested after attempted break-in in Tavernier, deputies say
Monroe County deputies arrested four juveniles after surveillance footage showed them trying to force entry into a an undisclosed area in the Florida Keys. The sheriff’s office reported the incident occurred late on a Friday evening and led to immedi
Key West officer returns to duty after Big Pine Key house fire
A house fire on Big Pine Key sent two local law enforcement officers to the hospital and destroyed their home, Monroe County authorities say. The blaze occurred on May 7 and resulted in both occupants being flown by Trauma Star to HCA Florida Kendall
Lower Keys operation leads to 15 arrests in alleged human‑trafficking and online chld‑exploitation probe
Monroe County law enforcement reported a multi‑agency operation in the Lower Keys that resulted in the arrest of 15 people on s3x‑related charges. The Monroe County Sheriff’s Office said the operation targeted human trafficking and the online exploit
Multiagency probe in Lower Keys leads to 15 arrests on Prosti and online solicitation allegations
Monroe County law enforcement says a coordinated investigation in the Lower Keys resulted in 15 arrests this week on allegations tied to human trafficking, online chld exploitation and other illegal s3xual activity. The Monroe County Sheriff’s Office
Monroe County begins demolition of Sugarloaf Key fire station to build replacement
Monroe County crews have begun preparatory work to demolish the existing Sugarloaf Key fire station and replace it with a new two-story facility on Sugarloaf Key in Monroe County, Florida. According to county materials, work launched the week of Octo
Key West bicycle stops led to arrests and transfer to federal immigration authorities, community group says
Key West police stopped and arrested two people on alleged bicycle traffic violations in early October in Key West, according to a local community letter. The letter says officers arrested a person at 2:10 p.m. on Oct. an undisclosed area and arreste
Person with cognitive disability located near Mile Marker 7 after wrong turn on tricycle in Monroe County
Monroe County deputies and fire-rescue personnel located an adult who had become disoriented and stopped at the shoulder near Mile Marker 7 on Oct. 5, 2026. The individual had been riding an adult tricycle and had stopped in the shade with fire ants
Marathon Council votes to pursue 100 early-evacuation workforce housing rights
The Marathon City Council voted on Oct. 13 to pursue a transfer of 100 early-evacuation workforce housing allocations from the neighboring municipalities of Key Colony Beach and Layton, a move intended to increase units available to Marathon’s workfo
Georgia woman arrested in Monroe County in alleged Zelle scam targeting Florida Keys couple
Monroe County deputies say a Georgia woman was arrested and jailed in connection with an alleged scam that targeted a Florida Keys couple. The Monroe County Sheriff’s Office reports the incident originated in December 2025 when the couple was contact
Florida Keys driver sentenced after DUI crash that left Monroe County deputy permanently injured
A driver from out of state was sentenced to four years in prison after a DUI crash on U.S. 1 in Islamorada that permanently injured a Monroe County deputy. The crash occurred April 9, 2024, when the defendant struck the rear of a patrol vehicle that
Woman arrested in Monroe County after alleged phone scam claiming law-enforcement ties
Monroe County deputies say a 37-year-old woman was arrested in connection with a December 2025 phone scam in which a local couple was told their son had been arrested and required payment for an ankle monitor. The Monroe County Sheriff's Office ident
Georgia woman arrested after Zelle scam targeting Key Haven couple leads to Monroe County booking
A Roswell, Georgia woman was arrested and booked into the Monroe County jail after a reported Zelle scam that targeted a couple in Key Haven, near Key West. The Monroe County Sheriff's Office identified the suspect as Johnay Monique Barnett, 37, and
Islamorada DUI crash that maimed Monroe County deputy results in prison sentence
A driver who struck a Monroe County Sheriff’s patrol vehicle during an April 9, 2024 traffic stop in Islamorada has been sentenced following a negotiated plea. The collision, which occurred on U.S. 1 near mile marker 87, pushed the patrol vehicle int
Drunk driving conviction in Islamorada after deputy struck during traffic stop
A woman has been sentenced after investigators say she struck a Monroe County Sheriff’s Office deputy during a traffic stop in Islamorada. The crash occurred in April 2024 near mile marker 87; authorities report the deputy was conducting a traffic st