Crime
Man arrested after alleged unauthorized charges at Islamorada resort
Monroe County deputies arrested a 26-year-old Clearwater man on Oct. 3 after an Islamorada resort guest reported unauthorized charges to her room. The Cheeca Lodge & Spa called the sheriff’s office in September 2025 when a guest discovered nearly $900 in drinks, food, clothing and sundries had been placed on her bill without her knowledge, according to the sheriff’s office. Resort security identified additional unauthorized transactions and issued reimbursements; detectives say the total value of goods and services charged without consent was approximately $2,419. Sheriff’s office detectives worked with resort security and the Clearwater Police Department during the investigation. Warrants were later sought for a second suspect in the case. Malachi Ethan Keasler, 26, was arrested Oct. 3 and charged with grand theft, possession of another person’s identification (over the age of 60) and scheme to defraud, according to the booking information. A codefendant, Emma Camille Wallace, 24, of Hollywood, Florida, was previously arrested and booked in December 2025 on related charges. Agency records show Keasler was booked into Monroe County jail; prosecutors have been provided the investigative findings. The sheriff’s office describes the alleged conduct and the criminal charges; those allegations have an undisclosed area, and no trial outcome is documented in the agency release. All individuals accused of a crime are presumed innocent an undisclosed area.
More Monroe County news · Request a correction or case update
All individuals mentioned in criminal allegations are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in a court of law.