Local News
Georgia woman arrested after Zelle scam targeting Key Haven couple leads to Monroe County booking
A Roswell, Georgia woman was arrested and booked into the Monroe County jail after a reported Zelle scam that targeted a couple in Key Haven, near Key West. The Monroe County Sheriff's Office identified the suspect as Johnay Monique Barnett, 37, and charged her with grand theft; she was booked into the county jail on Tuesday, Oct. 13. Monroe County deputies say the investigation began in December 2025 when the Key Haven couple reported receiving phone calls from people claiming to work for the Seminole County jail. According to authorities, the callers told the couple their son had been arrested and that they needed to transfer $6,500 via Zelle to pay for an ankle monitor required for release. The couple complied and sent $6,500; when scammers later demanded an additional $9,000, the couple refused, cut off contact and reported the matter to the sheriff’s office. Investigators from Monroe County worked with multiple Georgia agencies — including the Forsyth County Sheriff’s Office, Atlanta Police Department and Alpharetta Police Department — and with banking partners to trace transactions. Deputies say they reviewed security camera footage, financial records and prior body-worn camera footage tied to similar scams; that evidence supported an arrest warrant for Barnett. The Monroe County Sheriff's Office confirmed the arrest and transfer to Monroe County custody but did not specify whether any of the allegedly stolen funds have been recovered or whether additional suspects are being sought. Charges of grand theft have been filed; beyond the booking, the agency has not provided further case status details. All individuals accused of a crime are presumed innocent an undisclosed area.
More Monroe County news · Request a correction or case update
All individuals mentioned in criminal allegations are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in a court of law.