Crime & Public Safety
Drunk driving conviction in Islamorada after deputy struck during traffic stop
A woman has been sentenced after investigators say she struck a Monroe County Sheriff’s Office deputy during a traffic stop in Islamorada. The crash occurred in April 2024 near mile marker 87; authorities report the deputy was conducting a traffic stop when he was hit by the oncoming vehicle. Monroe County investigators say the driver, an undisclosed area records as Alexandra Baraga, was driving with a blood alcohol level of 0.31% at the time of the collision. Video from the scene documented the deputy pinned between two cars. The deputy, identified by the agency as Julian Garcia, suffered catastrophic injuries that required amputation of his leg. Court records show Baraga, who was 26 at the time of the crash and later 29 at sentencing, entered a no-contest plea. The judge accepted the plea agreement and sentenced her to four years in prison and six years of probation. Those outcomes and the plea were reported by the prosecuting authority handling the case. The Monroe County Sheriff’s Office and first responders are credited in official accounts with lifesaving efforts and supporting the deputy through extensive rehabilitation. Agency information notes the deputy returned to law enforcement work after recovery. The case status is concluded as to sentencing; criminal penalties and probation an undisclosed area’s disposition.
More Monroe County news · Request a correction or case update
All individuals mentioned in criminal allegations are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in a court of law.