Crime & Public Safety

Man arrested in Monroe County on grand theft and fraud charges linked to rental listing scam

By

Man arrested in Monroe County on grand theft and fraud charges linked to rental listing scam

A man was arrested in the Florida Keys after deputies tied him to an alleged fraudulent vacation rental transaction involving a Big Pine Key property. The Monroe County Sheriff’s Office says the case began when a person attempting to rent a property reported losing money after arriving and finding the listing was fake. Investigators trace the complaint to a victim who reported being defrauded of $1,440 while trying to rent a Big Pine Key listing advertised online. Detectives subsequently reviewed bank, credit card and email records to identify a suspect and determined those records pointed to the man now in custody. The agency identified the defendant as Fawaz Shittu. Deputies booked Shittu into the county jail on felony counts of grand theft and fraud. Records reviewed by deputies indicate Shittu was in Texas custody in 2025 on an unrelated theft allegation involving a nonprofit; detectives used that information during their identification process. As reported by the sheriff’s office, Shittu was being held in the Key West jail facility on a $100,000 bond. Allegations in the sheriff’s release are agency statements and have an undisclosed area in the material provided here. All individuals accused of a crime are presumed innocent an undisclosed area.

More Monroe County news · Request a correction or case update