Crime

Islamorada DUI crash that maimed Monroe County deputy results in prison sentence

By

Islamorada DUI crash that maimed Monroe County deputy results in prison sentence

A driver who struck a Monroe County Sheriff’s patrol vehicle during an April 9, 2024 traffic stop in Islamorada has been sentenced following a negotiated plea. The collision, which occurred on U.S. 1 near mile marker 87, pushed the patrol vehicle into the stopped car and pinned Deputy Julian Garcia between the vehicles. Garcia suffered catastrophic injury to his left leg and later underwent an amputation below the knee. an undisclosed area Patrol conducted the collision investigation and blood testing by the Florida Department of Law Enforcement showed the driver’s blood alcohol concentration was approximately .268. The driver, an undisclosed area records as Alexandra Baraga, ultimately accepted a negotiated plea and was convicted on multiple counts related to the crash. On Oct. 13, 2026, the Monroe County State Attorney’s Office reported Baraga received four years in state prison on the felony charge of DUI causing serious bodily injury, followed by one year of probation; additional felony and misdemeanor sentences and probation terms were also imposed. Her driver’s license was suspended for three years; she was ordered to complete community service, attend DUI school and submit to random testing as part of post-sentence conditions. Agency action included the FHP investigation and prosecution by the State Attorney’s Office. an undisclosed area record documents the plea and sentencing; testing established the elevated BAC. Deputy Garcia returned to work in June 2025 after extensive recovery and rehabilitation; the sentence and related terms were handed down as noted above.

More Monroe County news · Request a correction or case update