Crime & Public Safety

Sheriff: Two arrested in series of golf-cart thefts in Lake Sumter Landing

By

Sheriff: Two arrested in series of golf-cart thefts in Lake Sumter Landing
County Crime Watch original headline graphic.

Sumter County detectives say two men have been arrested after an inquiry into multiple golf-cart thefts in the Lake Sumter Landing area. Investigators linked the suspects to incidents reported between Oct. 24 and Nov. 10 and allege the carts were hot-wired, rekeyed and moved to other local businesses before attempts were made to resell them online.

The Sumter County Sheriff's Office reports that detectives recovered three stolen golf carts during the probe; two had been reported to the sheriff’s office and one to Lady Lake police. Arrests were announced following the investigative work. David Timothy Andrews was taken into custody and is charged with narcotics possession, violation of probation and three counts of grand theft. Steven Santiago was arrested and faces four counts of grand theft.

Agency officials say the suspects allegedly used Facebook Marketplace to try to sell the carts after taking them, then returned to retrieve vehicles left at drop-off locations. The sheriff’s office is continuing the investigation to identify any additional victims, recover more stolen property and determine whether others were involved.

Anyone with information is asked to contact the Sumter County Sheriff’s Office or call Crimeline to remain anonymous, as the office has requested. The case remains under active investigation according to the sheriff’s office release.

All individuals accused of a crime are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.

More Sumter County news · Request a correction or case update