Crime & Public Safety

Naples woman sues Collier sheriff after allegedly forged text prompted arrest

By

Naples woman sues Collier sheriff after allegedly forged text prompted arrest

A Naples woman has filed a lawsuit against the Collier County sheriff and an investigating deputy, alleging a fabricated text message led to her arrest in Collier County. The plaintiff, Melissa Sims, says her second arrest stemmed from a screenshot her ex‑boyfriend provided to investigators that purported to show a message violating a no‑contact order.

According to court and arrest records, Sims was first arrested in November 2024 on a battery allegation involving her ex‑boyfriend. Two months later she was again taken into custody, accused of violating the no‑contact order based on the allegedly sent text message. Sims and her defense attorney later reviewed phone records which they say show the text was never actually sent or received.

The state attorney ultimately dropped the violation charge, and a jury later found Sims not guilty on the original November battery charge. Sims has accused the Collier County Sheriff’s Office of conducting “sloppy, inadequate and unconstitutional” work and says she seeks accountability and policy changes; she is pursuing monetary damages in the new suit against Sheriff Kevin Rambosk and investigating officer Pierre Richard Jean.

A sheriff’s office spokesperson told reporters the agency does not comment on pending litigation. The case remains in litigation, with the lawsuit initiated after the criminal charges were dismissed and a not‑guilty verdict was returned in the underlying battery case.

All individuals accused of a crime are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.

More Collier County news · Request a correction or case update