Crime & Public Safety

Manatee County churches targeted in alleged mail-theft check fraud; eight arrested, investigation active

By

Manatee County churches targeted in alleged mail-theft check fraud; eight arrested, investigation active
County Crime Watch original headline graphic.

Manatee County law enforcement says a multi-jurisdictional check-fraud scheme targeted donation mail intended for area churches. The Manatee County Sheriff’s Office reported that checks taken from church mailboxes were cashed or deposited into suspects’ accounts, often using mobile banking, and that the inquiry remains ongoing.

Detectives trace the probe to December 2025 after a Lakewood Ranch congregation reported an unexplained decline in mail deliveries. Investigators allege that hundreds of stolen checks were identified across multiple counties and that the pattern expanded to at least 17 churches within Manatee County. Officials say the total identified losses outside Manatee County are nearly $194,000.

Agency action has produced eight arrests to date; detectives have identified roughly more than 20 suspects in the larger scheme and say seven additional suspects are still wanted. The Manatee County Sheriff’s Office alleges suspects stole donation checks from mailboxes, then deposited them into their own accounts, frequently via mobile deposit. Detective Rachael Fossaceca told investigators the suspects did not have ties to the targeted churches.

Allegations reported by the sheriff’s office remain under active investigation. No convictions or court outcomes are documented in the agency release, and the sheriff’s office continues to pursue additional suspects and evidence.

More Manatee County news · Request a correction or case update