Crime & Public Safety
Judge keeps felony animal-cruelty case alive against Palm City trainer after motion denied
A Martin County judge denied a motion to dismiss the felony animal cruelty case against Palm City dog trainer Nikki Camerlengo, meaning the prosecution will proceed though no trial date has been set. Prosecutor Kristen Chase confirmed the ruling occurred during a 9 a.m. hearing before Judge Elizabeth Metzger.
Camerlengo, owner of Pawsitively Paradise in Palm City, was arrested in June 2024 on two felony animal cruelty charges after Martin County detectives said two dogs died while in her care. The motion denied by Metzger was the defense’s second amended request to throw out the charges; prosecutors filed an opposition arguing the amended motion was procedurally invalid and facially insufficient.
The case has been delayed repeatedly for more than two years, with the trial pushed back at least nine times amid disputes over expert witnesses and witness availability. Prosecutors say necropsies of two dogs determined they died from blunt force trauma; the arrest followed an investigation that linked at least seven dog deaths or serious injuries to the facility over about a decade.
Defense attorney Stuart Kaplan has sought to exclude testimony from the Texas veterinary pathologist who performed the necropsies and from the lead detective. A key witness is on medical disability and prosecutors said she will be unable to testify until at least the end of January 2027. Camerlengo’s next court date is a docket sounding scheduled for Dec. 1; no trial date has been announced.
All individuals accused of a crime are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.
More Martin County news · Request a correction or case update
All individuals mentioned in criminal allegations are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in a court of law.