Crime & Public Safety

Chancellor withdraws from Shelby County school takeover lawsuit; case reassigned

By

Chancellor withdraws from Shelby County school takeover lawsuit; case reassigned
County Crime Watch original headline graphic.

A Chancery Court judge assigned to the lawsuit challenging Tennessee’s takeover law for Memphis-Shelby County Schools recused herself in Memphis on Friday, Oct. 9. Chancellor Melanie Taylor Jefferson invoked Tennessee Supreme Court Rule 10, saying a judge must disqualify when impartiality might reasonably be questioned, according to court reporting.

The verified complaint was filed Oct. 7 by multiple local parties, including Shelby County Government, Memphis-Shelby County Schools (MSCS), the County Commission, elected school board members and residents. Plaintiffs ask the court to block Tenn. Code Ann. § 49-1-616 and name the governor, the state education commissioner, the House speaker, the lieutenant governor and all nine members of the state oversight board in the suit.

In the filing plaintiffs allege the statute creates a nine-member state-appointed board with authority to veto the school budget, reject contracts exceeding $50,000, hire and fire the superintendent, override charter decisions and effectively stall the County Commission’s budget until the school budget is approved. Those claims are stated in the complaint and attributed to the plaintiffs.

After the recusal the case was referred for random reassignment; as of the next reported Tuesday afternoon it had not been reassigned. No trial dates, rulings on the merits, or enforcement actions are documented in the available reporting.

More Shelby County news · Request a correction or case update