Crime & Public Safety

Belleview Pet-Sitter Charged After $85,000 Jewelry Theft Reported to Marion County Deputies

By

Belleview Pet-Sitter Charged After $85,000 Jewelry Theft Reported to Marion County Deputies
County Crime Watch original headline graphic.

A Belleview resident is accused of stealing roughly $85,000 in jewelry from a homeowner while serving as a pet-sitter, Marion County Sheriff’s Office records allege. The homeowner reported two high-value bracelets and about 200 rings missing and told deputies the suspect had a key and was permitted to enter the residence to care for animals.

According to the arrest report, the theft was reported to deputies on October 9. Investigators found no signs of forced entry and say pawn shop records showed recurring transactions by the suspect beginning in August 2026 that matched the descriptions of the missing items. Deputies recovered a stolen charm bracelet and a gold pendant that remained in a shop’s inventory.

The report states the suspect, identified as 54-year-old Keith Francis Verner, sent a text message to the victim on October 11 in which he allegedly acknowledged pawning some of the jewelry “on a couple occasions” because he was “struggling” and “needed extra money,” an MCSO corporal noted. A warrant was issued and Verner was taken into custody and booked into the Marion County Jail on October 21.

Verner faces multiple felony charges, including one count of grand theft, 12 counts of dealing in stolen property, and 12 counts of providing false ownership information to a pawnbroker. Jail records show he posted a $50,000 bond and was released the following day. Court records list a Marion County courtroom appearance scheduled for 9 a.m. on November 24. Current allegations and evidence are as documented in the sheriff’s report and related booking records.

All individuals accused of a crime are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.

More Marion County news · Request a correction or case update